comic books review superheroes

Batman: Year Three

I recently recorded an episode of Views from the Longbox with Michael Bailey in which we covered the 1988 story “Batman: Death in the Family“.  The episode should be available for download within in a few weeks.  “Death in the Family” is the story in which the second Robin, Jason Todd, was murdered by the Joker.  … Sorry if I spoiled anything for you there.  You should probably be caught up enough in your reading to know about that. If not, my bad. I mean, it only came out 20 years ago.

Reading that story inspired me next to re-read the 1989 stories “Batman: Year Three” and “Batman: A Lonely Place of Dying“.  “Batman: Year Three” chronicles the third year of Batman’s crime fighting life, the year Dick Grayson came to live with him and became Robin.  Published immediately after “Batman: Year Three”  was “Batman: A Lonely Place of Dying”.  That story is set in modern times and tells the story of teenager Tim Drake and his desperate attempt to reunite Batman and Dick Grayson (now known as Nightwing).  During his quest, Tim Drake finds himself becoming the newest Robin.

So I’m only two issues into my new reading assignment, but I just gotta rave about “Batman: Year Three”  — well, at least Parts 1 & 2.  Wow!  What great comics!  First off, check out the amazing cover below for Part 1.  George Perez did an outstanding job depicting the death of Dick Grayson’s parents, while wrapping other story elements around the image.  Just a truly iconic cover.

Batman Year Three

The inside isn’t disappointing either.  Pat Broderick’s interior art is impressive!  His facial expressions always communicate exactly what the character is feeling.  He is also a master of creating a sense of motion in his work.  Finally, in this comic there are typically 6 panels per page (some with as many as 10 panels).  This is something you just don’t see in modern comics any more.  The panel per page count is WAY down nowadays.

The reoccurring theme throughout “Batman: Year Three” is that Batman is over the edge.  Just months before, Batgirl was crippled by the Joker.  Shortly after that, Robin was murdered.  Batman is mentally traumatized and descending into a brutal existence.  Despite a long-standing strained parental relationship, Dick Grayson returns to try and help Batman mentally recover.  This provides the framework to tell how Dick Grayson came to live with Bruce Wayne and eventually became Robin.

I won’t go into too much detail here because we’re going to review these stories on an upcoming “Views from the Longbox” podcast.  However, I have to compliment Marv Wolfman for putting together a phenomenal story.  It’s structured incredibly well with three intertwining plots — Batman trying to stop an organized crime killing spree, Dick Grayson trying to reach Batman emotionally, and Alfred doing what he feels is right to protect his loved ones.

Each issue is packed with story and you walk away feeling like your time was definitely worth it.  This is Marv Wolfman at the top of his game.  It’s a real shame “Batman: Year Three” has never been collected into a trade paperback.  I guess it probably never will be now, since the more recent “Batman: Dark Victory” provides a slightly different origin for Dick Grayson’s Robin.

If you don’t own these issues, you can pick them up dirt cheap at Mile High Comics right now.  “Batman: Year Three” runs through  Batman issues #436-#439.  Seriously, at the time of this writing you can buy all four issues from Mile High for a combined total of $3.05 plus shipping.  If you also want to pick up “Batman: A Lonely Place of Dying”, that story runs through Batman issues #440-442, and New Titans issues #60-61.  That story will set you back a whopping $5.20 plus shipping (at the time of this writing).  It’s a great time to buy back issues if you are interested.

If you already own these issues, I highly recommend you dig them out and re-read them.  I think you’ll  find a satisfying story that offers a quality and quantity that seems to be lacking in most comics nowadays.

4 thoughts on “Batman: Year Three

  1. Fabulous post. As dated as “A Lonely Place of Dying” is, I’m glad I bought and re-read it. It put so many things into context for me, and now I must read “Batman: Year Three.” Please let us know when the podcast is available for download! Another great thing about that whole arc is that it got a lot of people back into comics again.

  2. “A Lonely Place of Dying” is a big part of the reason I could never take the 1990s “Batman is an urban legend” thing seriously. A key element of Tim Drake’s origin is that he saw footage of Batman and Robin on television and recognized Robin as Dick Grayson because he used a particular acrobatic move.

Leave a Reply